050 - Implementing international efforts to combat the sale of illegal wildlife products online

050 - Implementing international efforts to combat the sale of illegal wildlife products online

Latest version in this language: Version for electronic vote | Published on: 30 Sep 2021

DEEPLY CONCERNED by the severe threat that wildlife trafficking poses to the survival of protected species, local communities and the rule of law;

AWARE that the relative anonymity of internet commerce and its ease of use allow a range of illegal wildlife and wildlife products to be trafficked to a wider market than ever before;

RECOGNISING IUCN’s efforts to address environmental and conservation crimes and protect the most frequently trafficked species;

RECALLING Resolution 6.070 Crimes against the environment (Hawai‘i, 2016), which, inter alia, encourages collaboration amongst relevant actors to examine and provide legal and policy expertise to respond to environmental crimes;

FURTHER RECALLING Resolution 6.076 Improving the means to fight environmental crime (Hawai‘i, 2016), which, inter alia, calls for the strengthening of environmental criminal laws;

WELCOMING steps taken to address wildlife crime linked to the internet by Parties to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES);

FURTHER WELCOMING efforts to combat cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking including the Global Action on Cybercrime Extended (GLACY)+, Global Wildlife Cybercrime Action Plan, the first cross-sector partnership of enforcers, NGOs and academics linking policy and private sector initiatives, and the Coalition to End Wildlife Trafficking Online, which includes more than 30 of the world’s leading online technology companies;

NOTING the value of the Convention on Cybercrime in assisting countries to develop national legislation, and as a framework for international cooperation between state actors;

ALSO NOTING increased public awareness and public reporting channels, and that a freer exchange of information, expertise and best practices among interested parties would improve the detection, disruption and deterrence of cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking;

RECOGNISING that law enforcement is strengthened when witnesses to crime are encouraged, financially and otherwise, to provide information (‘blow the whistle’) through appropriate mechanisms to prosecutors and other law enforcement as appropriate, and are protected from retaliation when they do so;

NOTING with concern that the authorities of many countries concerned do not encourage and protect whistleblowers and therefore regularly miss opportunities to identify and prosecute wildlife trafficking;

APPLAUDING steps taken already by some governments to address cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking, including by amending legislation, enhancing enforcement capacity and engaging private, academic and non-government sectors; and

NOTING that the growth of online marketplaces for illicit goods makes the current period a critical juncture in time;

The IUCN World Conservation Congress, at its session in Marseille, France:

1. REQUESTS the Director General, in collaboration with the Commissions, to facilitate efforts to reduce and eliminate cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking by:

a. assisting IUCN Members to convene a cross-sector workshop to review progress and best practices in tackling cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking;

b. reviewing examples of national legislation addressing cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking and making recommendations on best practices; and

c. contributing to awareness-raising efforts about cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking;

2. ENCOURAGES governments, intergovernmental organisations and other relevant IUCN Members and stakeholders, as appropriate, to implement measures outlined in the Global Wildlife Cybercrime Action Plan and INTERPOL’s Guidelines on Wildlife Crime Linked to the Internet;

3. RECOMMENDS that governments adopt best-practice enforcement models and utilise INTERPOL’s Guidelines on Wildlife Crime Linked to the Internet;

4. CALLS ON governments to:

a. strengthen legislation to address cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking ​​​​​​where appropriate;

b. collaborate across departments and sectors, and with other countries, to enhance the detection, investigation and disruption of cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking;

c. actively encourage, protect and otherwise support whistleblowers who are willing and able to provide information for the prosecution of wildlife trafficking;

d. encourage technology companies to improve efforts to tackle cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking; and ​​

e. raise awareness of their citizens concerning wildlife trade-related regulations and the requirements pertaining to them;

5. ENCOURAGES governments, international funding mechanisms and IUCN Members to increase resources available to tackle cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking; ​and

6. FURTHER ENCOURAGES Parties to the Convention on Cybercrime which have not yet ratified the Convention, and states which have not yet become Party to the Convention, to consider doing so;

7. ENCOURAGES members engaged in other forums addressing broader cybercrime issues, such as the Convention on Cybercrime and GLACY+, to consider how measures under those forums could be applied to tackling cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking; and

8. ASKS non-governmental organisation (NGO) Members to monitor and report cyber-enabled wildlife trafficking to companies and enforcement agencies, and to raise awareness of this threat with their supporters.

The internet allows wildlife traffickers to exploit access to a vast international marketplace – one that is borderless, anonymous, and open 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Disrupting wildlife cybercrime is a critical component to ensure the survival of threatened wild animals and plants.

Research has found thousands of endangered wildlife products and live animals for sale over the internet, such as ivory, rhino horn products, taxidermy, fur and skins from endangered big cats (cheetah, leopard, lion, tiger) and both live big cats and primates (orangutans, gorillas). Studies have also uncovered significant trade in protected live parrots, birds of prey, and numerous reptiles and amphibians.

Investigations by IFAW, TRAFFIC, the Wildlife Justice Commission and others have uncovered such products and live animals for sale on various online marketplaces and social media platforms, worth many millions of dollars. These investigations have been limited in time and in scope, thus these results are just the tip of the iceberg.

Technology companies are a key stakeholder when tackling wildlife cybercrime. In March 2018 The Coalition to End Wildlife Trafficking Online was formed. It unites online technology companies across continents in partnership with experts WWF, TRAFFIC and IFAW to reduce wildlife trafficking online by 80% by 2020. It includes over 30 companies, including some of the most recognized names in technology such as eBay, Facebook, Google, Instagram, Microsoft, Tencent, Alibaba and Baidu.

NGO engagement with companies, including via The Coalition to End Wildlife Trafficking Online, has led to the removal of thousands of suspected illegal wildlife posts. This includes eBay removing or blocking 165,000 listings between 2017 – 2019; Baidu cleaning up more than 276,700 illegal wildlife trade listings, shutting down 44 online groups and banning 94 users permanently on Baidu’s online forums from 2018 to May 2019; and 5,800 WeChat accounts being blocked since Tencent launched ‘Tencent for the planet’ in 2015.

To combat wildlife cybercrime it is essential to create a network to defeat a criminal network. At the Illegal Wildlife Trade Conference in London during October 2018 the Global Wildlife Cybercrime Action Plan was launched in partnership with IFAW, WWF, TRAFFIC, INTERPOL, the Oxford Martin School, and the Durrell Institute of Conservation and Ecology (DICE). The Action Plan aims to enhance cooperation, communication and collaboration across all key sectors, empowering governments, enforcers, companies, intergovernmental organisations, non-governmental organisations and academics to detect and disrupt wildlife cybercriminals.

IUCN’s global convening power and influence is well-placed to further enhance efforts to combat wildlife cybercrime by encouraging the necessary collaboration between sectors. A motion on wildlife cybercrime would also contribute directly to fulfilment of the stated commitment to fight environmental crime by “focusing on the illegal trafficking of flora and fauna” in the proposed IUCN Programme for 2021-2024, under the Programme Area ‘Equitable Governance of Natural Resources’.
  • African Wildlife Foundation - Kenya HQ [Kenya]
  • Association Française des Parcs Zoologiques [France]
  • Association Française du Fonds Mondial pour la Nature - France [France]
  • Cheetah Conservation Fund [Namibia]
  • Environmental Education Center Zapovedniks [Russia]
  • International Fund for Animal Welfare [United States of America]
  • Ministère des Affaires étrangères et du Développement international [France]
  • Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle [France]
  • Natural Resources Defense Council [United States of America]
  • Polskie Towarzystwo Ochrony Przyrody ''Salamandra'' [Poland]
  • The Syrian Society for the Conservation of Wildlife [Syria]
  • Wildlife Trust of India [India]
  • World Wide Fund for Nature - Belgium [Belgium]
  • World Wide Fund for Nature - International [Switzerland]

Hosts